All carrier audits

British Airways

BA cited Heathrow fog on BA-117 — while 8 widebodies took off on RWY 27R under 8,000m visibility.

UK/EU · Long-Haul & Short-Haul · EU Regulation 261/2004 & UK261 Article 5/7 · Heathrow RWY 27R Slot Proof + €600 Enforcement

68.5%

of British Airways “bad weather” excuses rebutted on telemetry

450 audited flights · 74.2% originally blamed weather/ATC · Flagship trace: BA-117 · LHR → JFK

Selective Weather (RWY Open)44.0%
Inbound Long-Haul Knock-On26.5%
Tarmac Tow / Gate Tug Hold14.3%
Reserve Crew Missing9.7%
Connecting Flight Missed5.5%

European airlines regularly reject initial €250–€600 EC261 claims by invoking "extraordinary weather". Under Wallentin-Hermann and settled CJEU precedent, carriers must prove external impossibility—easily disproved when peer jets take off on the identical runway.

Radar findings & monthly rebuttal share

Rebutted weather exemptions across audited sectors

Verified against METAR VMC & parallel runway departures

0%40%80%Jan 26Mar 26May 26Jul 26Sept 26Nov 26Nov 26: 69.2% rebutted

Peer-runway comparison at EGLL RWY 27R disproved 68.5% of rejected "fog/wind" EU261 denials.

Cross-referencing OMDB→LHR inbound rotation logs exposed pre-existing technical seals swapped hours prior.

UK CAA / EU NEB escalation rate doubled recovery on previously abandoned €600 long-haul claims.

How the statutory contradiction unfolds

TimelineDetectorVerified Record
04:10 GST (Inbound)Tail Rotation FaultG-XWBA cargo door seal replacement in Dubai left BA-117 160m behind.
10:20 GMTSelective WeatherEGLL METAR 8000m VMC; 8 widebodies (VS-45, AA-107, UA-17...) cleared off 27R.
11:30 GMTEU261 €600 SealedWallentin-Hermann rebuttal packet signed with Heathrow ADS-B coordinates.